We need to ban Bitcoins. But Do we need a Digital Rupee?

The new law set to be passed in the Parliament as “Banning of Crypto Currency and Regulation of Official Digital Currency Act 2019” is designed to ban Bitcoin and other privately managed crypto currencies.

However the law may permit the creation of an Official Crypto Currency called “Digital Rupee” and use of “Block Chain” as a technology for purposes other than creating “Crypto Currencies”. The law may also recognize “Official Crypto Currencies” if any from other sovereign nations as “Foreign digital currency”.

India already has a well developed Digital Banking system and hence the additional benefit that can be expected from the Digital Rupee is minimal.

While mining of Digital Rupee under record from the Central authority may ensure that no “Unaccounted Digital Rupee” is created,  the risk of a “Split Block” being created deliberately or by error continues to exist.

Before every new block is authenticated and appended to the core block, there is a time gap in which a transaction remains unauthenticated. This is the time when double spend can happen and unwary customers may get duped. Currently the “Virtual Banking Transactions” happen within a real time session and there is a certainty whether a transaction is through or not. Block chain concept may extend this window of uncertainty which is not desirable.

Also giving an opportunity to people to mine “Digital Rupee” will create a needless overhead on the use of computing resources, consumption of electricity, redundant data consumption as well as the possibility of proliferation of “unauthorized mining scripts” being implanted as a computer contaminant in user’s computers without their knowledge etc will continue.

Hence the concept of “Digital Rupee” included in the proposed law should be seen as an “Enabling Provision” and there is no need for RBI to jump into making use of this provision. There would be a need for a separate Risk Assessment to ensure that this does not pose a risk of “Fake Digital Rupees” getting into circulation.

Naavi

 

 

Posted in Cyber Law | Leave a comment

Bill to ban Bitcoin Introduced in Parliament

The budget session 2021 of the Indian Parliament is being eagerly watched for several reasons. While the traditional financial pundits will look forward to the Post Covid budget to take the country on a revival path, observers of the Data Privacy scenario are waiting for the PDPB 2019 to be introduced for final passage with the amendments suggested by the JPC. This bill is yet to be placed before the Parliament as it has to be cleared first by the Cabinet. This may happen during the end of week 1 of the session.

In the meantime, the much awaited bill to regulate crypto currency system and to more specifically, ban the Bitcoin and its brother crypto systems which are the “Digital Black Money” of India is being taken up in the Parliament for discussions and passage during this session.

Considering the high stakes of political parties in Bitcoins and crypto currencies, we may expect a fight to scuttle this bill in this session much more than the fight on the farm bills. However, it is our hope that the bill will finally be passed and one of the long fought battles of Naavi.org will come to a welcome conclusion.

The Bill is called “Banning of Crypto Currency & Regulation of Official Digital Currency Bill 2019” (Crypto bill). It has 27 sections.

According to the Act,

Whoever directly or indirectly mines, generates, holds, sells, deals in, transfers, disposes of or issues Cryptocurrency or any combination thereof or

Whoever directly or indirectly promotes, issues any advertisement, solicits, abets or induces any participation in any activity involving the use of Cryptocurrency

shall be punishable with imprisonment which may go upto 10 years and a fine upto Rs 25 crores.

The second schedule makes consequential amendments to the Money Laundering Act 2002 and brings mining, holding, selling, dealing in, advertising, soliciting etc etc of Crypto currencies within the provisions of this Act under which an imprisonment of upto  10 years is provided for.

The definition of Crypto currency as per the Act is

―Cryptocurrency‖, by whatever name called, means any information or code or number or token not being part of any Official Digital Currency, generated through cryptographic means or otherwise, providing a digital representation of value which is exchanged with or without consideration, with the promise or representation of having inherent value in any business activity which may involve risk of loss or an expectation of profits or income, or functions as a store of value or a unit of account and includes its use in any financial transaction or investment, but not limited to, investment schemes;

The Act at the same time introduces the concept of an official crypto currency which may be called a “Digital Rupee”. The Act recognizes “Foreign Digital Currency” as “any class, category or type of digital currency recognised as legal tender in a foreign jurisdiction;”.

The prohibition under the Act is that

” No person shall mine, generate, hold, sell, deal in, issue, transfer, dispose of or use Cryptocurrency in the territory of India.”

Exception are available for research, education and does not affect the use of blockchain technology.

The possible recognition of a foreign digital currency is an enablement which requires specific notification.

Prohibition also extends to use of Crypto currency as a medium of exchange or a store of value or a unit of account and as a legal tender or currency in any place in India.

It may be noted that

Where a violation under this Act has been committed by a body corporate, every officer of the body corporate who at the time the violation was committed, was in charge of, and was responsible to, the body corporate for the conduct of the business of the body corporate, as well as the body corporate, shall be liable for the commission of the violation;

Provided that an officer of a body corporate shall not be liable to be proceeded against for a violation committed by the body corporate under this Act, unless such violation is, – (a) shown to have been committed with the consent or connivance of that officer; (b) shown to have been committed with the knowledge of that officer, attributable to such officer due to the internal processes of the body corporate; or (c) attributable to the gross neglect on the part of the officer.

The passage of the bill will bring the long standing demand of Naavi.org to a conclusion. We hope the passage of the bill goes through without a problem.

We would like to point out the authorities to however include in the rules an exception that the definition of “Crypto Currency” as per Section 2(1)(a) does not include the value of Non Personal Data proposed to be unlocked in the “Non Personal Data Governance” regulation as envisaged.

P.S: The explanation that may be added could be as follows:

Explanation : The definition of “Crypto Currency” above excludes value assigned to any set of data  representing an inherent right such as a domain name, trademark, copyright, patent or other right classified as an Intellectual property, and also any valuation of “data” or “personal data” as defined under Information Technology Act 2000.

Naavi

(Earlier articles on this site on Bitcoin may be accessed here)

 

Posted in Cyber Law | Leave a comment

Please donot misuse Naavi.org

I have been informed by some alert observers that some persons are contacting the visitors of Naavi.org who post comments and soliciting business of there own.

While building a network based on the interactions on a website outside the activities of the website cannot be objected to or prevented, Naavi.org cannot be an instrument to be used for spamming the persons who post comments or using the comments for unfair business gains.

I would request visitors to refrain from such practice.

I hereby give notice that Naavi.org is not associated with such persons and is not liable for any of their activities.

Naavi

Posted in Cyber Law | Leave a comment

Data Protection Journal of India launched

To mark the international privacy day of 2021, Foundation of Data Protection Professionals in India (FDPPI) launched a journal titled “Data Protection Journal of India”.

The journal will be available at www.dpji.in

Naavi

Posted in Cyber Law | Leave a comment

Privacy Challenge..Article published in India Legal Magazine

This is the article published in India Legal magazine dated January 25, 2021.

PDF link 

Posted in Cyber Law | Leave a comment

Zoho’s “Arattai” app to challenge WhatsApp

Zoho is an unique Indian Company that is promoted by Mr Sridhar Vembu, a man whose vision is an inspiration for many.

It appears that Mr Shridhar Vembu is responding to the call for an Indigenous app to replace Whats App.

The app is called Arattai.

I wish we all try this app. More details are available at https://www.arattai.in/

I have one suggestion for Arattai in terms of their terms of use. The app has indicated that dispute resolution is through a “Binding Arbitration”. However in India, since there is a statutory judicial process involving “Adjudication” to resolve disputes between the users of Arattai and the Company, the arbitration has to be non-binding.

DDMAC (Data Disputes Mediation and Arbitration Center) of FDPPI has therefore adopted  non binding arbitration as the means of dispute resolution in an online system.

Naavi

Posted in Cyber Law | Leave a comment